Based on results of the Big I New York Carrier Index Surveys for National, Super Regional, and Regional carriers.
2024
Top Carrier Partner Commercial Lines - Cincinnati
Top Carrier Partner Personal Lines - NYCM
2023
Top Carrier Partner Commercial Lines - Travelers
Top Carrier Partner Personal Lines - NYCM
2022
Top Carrier Partner Commercial Lines - Travelers
Top Carrier Partner Personal Lines - NYCM
2021
No honor awarded due to the pandemic.
2020
No honor awarded due to the pandemic.
2019
COMMERCIAL
Top Carrier Partner (Over $100 million in NY written premium) - Selective
Top Carrier Partner (Under $100 million in NY written premium) - Sterling Insurance Group
2018
Commercial
Top Carrier Partner (Over $100 million in NY written premium) - Merchants Insurance Group
Top Carrier Partner (Under $100 million in NY written premium) - Security Mutual; UPC/Interboro
2017
Commercial
Top Carrier Partner (Over $100 million in NY written premium) - Liberty Mutual
Top Carrier Partner (Under $100 million in NY written premium) - Utica First
Independent Agents Brand Champion - Merchants Insurance Group
Agency Talent Development Champion - Liberty Mutual
2016
Commercial
Outstanding Regional Commercial Lines Company Partner - Dryden Mutual
Outstanding Super Regional Commercial Lines Company Partner - Merchants Insurance Group
Outstanding National Commercial Lines Company Partner - Travelers
Personal
Outstanding Regional Personal Lines Company Partner - Sterling Insurance
Outstanding Super Regional Personal Lines Company Partner - Andover Companies
Outstanding National Personal Lines Company Partner - Travelers
2015
Commercial
Outstanding Regional Commercial Lines Company Partner - Erie & Niagara Insurance Association
Outstanding Super Regional Commercial Lines Company Partner - Merchants Insurance Group
Outstanding National Commercial Lines Company Partner - Utica National Insurance Group
Personal
Outstanding Regional Personal Lines Company Partner - Dryden Mutual Insurance Company
Outstanding Super Regional Personal Lines Company Partner - Merchants Insurance Group and NGM Insurance Company (tie)
Outstanding National Personal Lines Company Partner - The Travelers Companies
2014
Commercial
Outstanding Regional Commercial Lines Company Partner - Dryden Mutual Insurance Company
Outstanding Super Regional Commercial Lines Company Partner - Merchants Insurance Group
Outstanding National Commercial Lines Company Partner - CNA
Personal
Outstanding Regional Personal Lines Company Partner - Dryden Mutual Insurance Company
Outstanding Super Regional Personal Lines Company Partner - Andover Companies
Outstanding National Personal Lines Company Partner - Safeco Insurance
2013
CommercialOutstanding Regional Commercial Lines Company Partner - Dryden Mutual Insurance Company
Outstanding Super Regional Commercial Lines Company Partner - Preferred Mutual Insurance Company
Outstanding National Commercial Lines Company Partner - Chubb Group
Personal
Outstanding Regional Personal Lines Company Partner - Sterling Insurance
Outstanding Super Regional Personal Lines Company Partner - Preferred Mutual Insurance Company
Outstanding National Personal Lines Company Partner - Chubb Group
2012
CommercialOutstanding Regional Commercial Lines Company Partner - Sterling Insurance
Outstanding Super Regional Commercial Lines Company Partner - National Grange Mutual Insurance Co.
Outstanding National Commercial Lines Company - The Hartford
Personal
Outstanding Regional Personal Lines Company Partner - Sterling Insurance
Outstanding Super Regional Personal Lines Company Partner - Preferred Mutual
Outstanding National Personal Lines Company Partner - Partner Kemper, a Unitrin Business
2011
CommercialOutstanding Regional Commercial Lines Company Partner - Sterling Insurance
Outstanding Super Regional Commercial Lines Company Partner - Peerless
Outstanding National Commercial Lines Company Partner - Travelers
Personal
Outstanding Regional Personal Lines Company Partner - Dryden Mutual
Outstanding Super Regional Personal Lines Company Partner - Preferred Mutual
Outstanding National Personal Lines Company Partner- Kemper, a Unitrin Business
2010
Commercial Outstanding Regional Commercial Lines Company Partner - Dryden Mutual
Outstanding Super Regional Commercial Lines Company Partner - Peerless
Outstanding National Commercial Lines Company Partner - Chubb
Personal
Outstanding Regional Personal Lines Company Partner - Midstate Mutual
Outstanding Super Regional Personal Lines Company Partner - Safeco Insurance
Outstanding National Personal Lines Company Partner - Kemper, a Unitrin Business
2009
Commercial
Outstanding Regional Commercial Lines Company Partner - Dryden Mutual
Outstanding Super Regional Commercial Lines Company Partner - Selective
Outstanding National Commercial Lines Company Partner - The Hartford
Personal
Outstanding Regional Personal Lines Company Partner - Dryden Mutual
Outstanding Super Regional Personal Lines Company Partner - Peerless
Outstanding National Personal Lines Company Partner - Kemper
Outstanding Regional Company Partner - New York Central Mutual
Outstanding Super Regional Company Partner - Selective Insurance Company
Outstanding National Company Partner - Travelers